Manhattan, NY vs Staten Island, NY: Cost of Living Comparison
Staten Island has the lower overall cost of living. (100 = US national average)
Category-by-Category Comparison
| Category | Manhattan | Staten Island | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall cost of living | 218 | 151 | Staten Island |
| Housing | 318 ($1,492) | 189 ($1,182) | Staten Island |
| Transportation | 107 ($3.50) | 104 ($3.50) | Staten Island |
| Food & groceries | 140 ($574) | 132 ($541) | Staten Island |
| Utilities | 209 ($572) | 145 ($340) | Staten Island |
| Healthcare | 209 ($413) | 145 ($246) | Staten Island |
| Median annual wage | 123 ($59,670) | 123 ($59,670) | Tie |
Index 100 = US national average. Lower = cheaper. For wage, higher = better.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Manhattan, NY or Staten Island, NY cheaper to live in?
Staten Island, NY is cheaper overall by about 67 index points (Manhattan, NY: 218, Staten Island, NY: 151; 100 = US national average).
What salary do I need in Manhattan, NY vs Staten Island, NY?
A single adult needs roughly $76,300/year in Manhattan, NY and $52,850/year in Staten Island, NY to cover basic living costs.